Revlon 3D Extreme Mascara, $5.99
The promise of bold, dramatic lashes with "beautiful separation" appeared to many reviewers to be hype and not reality. Beauty testers were underwhelmed with this formula, which created gobs of mascara mush and mess, or as some called it, "goop." A few reviewers claimed eye irritation and others despised the lack of bristles on the mascara wand.