Best Eye Cream: Fresh
Black tea, blackberry leaf extract and noni fruit juice in this eye cream work together to improve the elasticity and appearance of skin, retain and increase moisture as well as reduce dark circles and puffiness in this cooling formula.
Fresh Black Tea Age-Delay Eye Concentrate, $85 at Amazon
Best Eye Cream: Neutrogena
Rid the appearance of crow's-feet, brighten the undereye area and smooth fine lines with this creamy formula packed with retinol SA and hyaluronic acid.
Neutrogena Rapid Wrinkle Repair Eye Cream, $13.49 at Amazon
Best Eye Cream: Eve Lom
Shea butter and rose hip oil minimize the appearance of fine lines, ginseng-derived jiaogulan diminishes puffiness and age-defying peptides reduce inflammation and discoloration, while it also works to tone and firm skin.
Eve Lom Eye Cream, $74.83 at Amazon
Worst Eye Cream: Juice Beauty
Promising to smooth fine lines with peptides, DMAE, coenzyme Q10 and vitamin C, many reviewers weren't all that impressed with this "age-defying" eye cream. One tester said "it isn't worth the price," while others said it was "nothing special." One reviewer noticed no decrease in dark circles and another said that others commented on how tired she looked while using the eye cream. Lastly, one reviewer couldn't even test the eye cream because the smell was too "horrendous."
Juice Beauty Nutrient Eye Cream, $38 at Amazon
Best Eye Cream: Clinique
The name of this best eye cream says it all. This lightweight, cream-gel formula works to brighten dark circles and reduce fine lines and puffiness, all while holding your makeup in place.
Clinique All About Eyes, $27.99 at Amazon
Best Eye Cream: Estée Lauder
This isn't the holy grail of best eye creams for no reason. There's no better way to get beauty sleep than to decrease any dryness, fine lines, dark circles, crow's-feet, unevenness and puffiness with a dab of this silky gel cream.
Estée Lauder Advanced Night Repair Eye Synchronized Complex II, $58 at Bloomingdale's
Best Eye Cream: Burt's Bees
When sensitive skin and puffy eyes join forces, this best eye cream uses cotton extract and olive fruit oil to help reduce irritation and redness while hydrating and brightening skin.
Burt's Bees Sensitive Eye Cream, $9.99 at Amazon
Worst Eye Cream: Physicians Formula
This affordable eye cream with provitamin B5 and a lightweight gel formula left reviewers underwhelmed with its performance. One reviewer experienced stinging, while another suffered red bumps and one even noticed an increase in dryness. Multiple reviewers claimed they saw no change to their undereye circles and felt their eyes became more puffy and irritated.
Physicians Formula Hydrating Eye Cream, $5.49 at Amazon
Best Eye Cream: RoC
With the help of retinol, this non-greasy moisturizing best eye cream helps improve the appearance of wrinkles, reduces puffiness and evens out dark circles. It'll also rid stubborn crow's-feet with consistent use.
RoC Retinol Correxion Eye Cream, $17.97 at Amazon
Eye creams, who needs them? Just about everyone, actually, no matter your age. While it’s beneficial to start using any anti-aging products at age 20, eye creams are often the most forgotten when it comes to skincare. Cleansing, toning and moisturizing skin does it justice, but it takes special ingredients to make sure the eye area is bright, smooth, depuffed and wrinkle-free. Here, we rank the worst and best eye creams to see which will leave you with tired eyes and which will make you look like you’ve gotten the best beauty sleep of all time. Take a look at the slideshow above to see which best eye creams are worth the splurge and which should be left on the shelf.