One thing’s for sure: October belongs to Kendall Jenner. Not only did the reality star turned model appear on Allure, but a whopping four Vogue covers as well. Gigi Hadid wasn’t far behind with a number of noteworthy cover appearances, leaving some to wonder what’s worse, a newsstand dominated by vanilla actresses or one dominated by underwhelming shots of reality star models. There were some welcome surprises this month, however, including a Vogue cover for Lupita Nyong’o, one for Luna Bijl and one for Victoria Beckham, who may as well be a model. Here’s a look at all of the aforementioned shots and more as we round up the best and worst of this month’s magazine covers.