"This doesn't look like her at all, more like a glorified MAC campaign, I'm afraid."
"A must-buy for me. She is so charismatic, a real queen!"
"She bores me to tears with this platinum pixie."
"I like how she looks but I hate the jacket."
"Perfect choice for a start of the year!"
"This looks like a candid from any of Chanel's shows, just with a dull backdrop."
"It's same old song but still good for December cover."
"It's nice to have a festive cover, love all the rich reds and the outfit."
"I like the idea, but where's the life? Testino's work used to show celebrities as glamorous and glowing!"
"Her face is too childlike and commercial to pull this off."