New York Fashion Week Spring 2018 may be over, but it left behind no shortage of buzz-worthy moments. Highs of the season included It girl Kaia Gerber‘s stunning debut on the runway at Calvin Klein, followed by appearances at Coach, Fenty x Puma, Alexander Wang and finally closing the Marc Jacobs show (and NYFW season). Jonathan Saunders received rave reviews (again) for his triumphant collection for Diane von Furstenberg. Amongst the lows were Tom Ford‘s questionable Dynasty-inspired collection and Oscar de la Renta‘s disappointing showing. Without further ado, here’s a look at all the hits and misses of NYFW Spring 2018, according to our no-holds-barred forum members.